In spite of the variety and quality of safety shoes available on the market, it is always surprising to see that one out of ten accidents happens to the feet. In many work environments, wearing safety shoes is mandatory given bad ground conditions or poor working conditions.
To properly protect your feet, it is important to choose shoes that will protect you against the risks that exist at your specific work station and to avoid shoes that protect against any risk at any work station.
Safety shoes are part of the personal protection equipment providing effective protection against a number of risks of foot injuries such as shock, crushing and puncture. However, it is important to be aware of the risks that are specific to your job.
Before buying a pair of safety shoes, make a list of the risks you want to avoid. This way, you will be able to rapidly identify the type of shoe you need to protect yourself.
Theoretically, a safety shoe is a shoe that meets at least one of the five criteria set by the Canadian Standards Association (CSA). You can find out what criteria a pair of safety shoes meets by consulting CSA's alphanumerical code found inside one of the shoes. The code is made up of five numbers or letters.
For instance, if the manufacturer of your street shoes had asked the CSA to assess its shoes, their safety code would probably be 000C0: no steel toe cap, no puncture-resistant sole, no metatarsus protector, are electrically conductive and provide no protection against chain saws.
Safety shoes also have tags on the outside.
Green Triangle: Class 1 steel toe cap with puncture-resistant sole;
Yellow Triangle
Yellow Triange: Class 2 steel toe cap with puncture-resistant sole;
No Triangle: No toe cap;
White Square: Electrical protection;
Yellow Square: Anti-Static protection;
Red Square: Electrically conductive;
Fir Tree: Protection against chain saws.
Do you own a pair of approved shoes? That's great! However, are they really suitable? There are several other safety criteria that the CSA does not cover but are nevertheless indispensable in certain work environments.
If you handle corrosive or irritant chemicals, or if you work with gravelly or hot substances, keeping these substances out of your shoes is preferable. In order to protect yourself, select a shoe with the tongue attached to the sides or shaped like a gusset.
If you sometimes work in places where surfaces are covered with chemicals like cement, lubricants, degreasers, removers, solvents or other chemicals being manufactured, ask to consult the material resistance table provided by the manufacturer before making your selection. These chemicals can easily destroy the materials in the soles and heels.
There are no real non-skid shoes. On dry clean surfaces, a smooth sole adheres better than a sole with treads. On soft surfaces such as snow, soles with large treads or crampons are effective. On slick and wet surfaces, soles having a medium tread provide some protection because the treads break up the liquid film spilled on the floor.
In mechanical workshops, metal filings are often found on the floor and it is best to avoid having them accumulate under shoes. The soles offering the best protection from metal filings are made of Vibram, Dynatread or crepe.
Welders and other foundry workers can add coverings on the tops of their shoes to protect themselves against burning metal spatters and to keep the laces from catching fire.
Some workers must often jump to complete certain tasks, for example: exiting a delivery truck where it is impossible to place a ladder or stairs to avoid jumping. The shock is felt mainly in the heels and in the ankles. To improve the situation, select shoes that have full or pimpled soles made of elastomer (shock-absorbing heels) and are equipped with ankle protectors (low boots).
If the risk of ankle injury is even greater and espeically if you want to prevent sprains on uneven terrain (on a construction site, for instance), use a high-cut boot that covers the ankle. Don't forget that for maximum protection, these boots must be completely tied.
If you work on hot floors, head-insulated soles made of wood or a multi-layer insulating material (generally elastomers such as neoprene, silicon nitrile and acrylic nitrile) are available. These soles are specially designed for work in hot conditions in places such as glass-works, foundries, steel plants, machine shops and boilerworks.
To protect yourself against cold conditions, you can add a felt or wool liner, not to mention all of the accessories you can find displayed in shop windows: rubber overshoes, winter boots, socklinings, waterproof ankle socks, ice cleats, gaiters...
With the exception of leather, all soles are water-resistant. If you work in a very wet environment or if you want effective protection against bad weather, rubber footwear may be necessary.
Safety shoes are a little stiffer than regular shoes, especially if they have steel toe caps and soles. Is there anything more unpleasant than wearing shoes that are uncomfortable or hurt your feet? Safety is not the only consideration when purchasing your shoes. To feel comfortable when wearing your shoes, take a look at the following comfort criteria.
Some manufacturers offer shoe models that could be mistaken for street shoes. There are safety running shoes, high-heel safety shoes, cowboy safety boots and even safety moccasins, firefighter boots and safety overshoes. Don't be fooled by style. Your feet must not feel any uncomfortable pressure once the shoes are tied or fastened.
A good shoe must have proper aeration to ensure that perspiration from your feet is drawn away. This may vary from 3 grams/hour when sitting to 15 grams/hour when running. Bad aeration causes foot temperature to increase and softens or swells the skin. This creates an environment that promotes the development of micro-organisms and the forming of cracks and blisters. Not to mention nasty odours!
The shoe that offers the best breathability is one made of lightly finished full-grain leather, the classic yellow leather! This type of leather is very permeable to perspiration.
You should also take a look at the inside of the shoe. The top sole should be made of leather or Synderm having a minimum thickness of 2 mm. These are the best shoes for absorbing perspiration.
Flexibility also means comfort. If you don't need a puncture-resistant sole, select a shoe that bends easily. Finding one is simple: walk around with your new shoes on before buying them and break them in.
Preferably select a leather model supple enough to stretch according to the variation in the volume of your feet when walking (from 2% to 4%) and to end of the day swelling. Here's a tip: purchase your shoes in the middle of the afternoon.
Shoes that are too heavy increase fatigue and require needless effort. A good pair of shoes should not weigh more than 1,300 grams.
In short, selecting a good pair of safety shoes is only logical:
Your feet will feel much better.
You can order copies of this document, indicating the departmental catalogue number from:
Publications Services
Human Resources and Skills Development Canada
140 Promenade du Portage
Phase IV, 12th Floor
Gatineau, Quebec
K1A 0J9
Fax: 819-953-7260
Online: Publicentre - Publication Search